Stone Money- Doglover846

The Value of Money

In today’s society, money is what the world revolves around. We use money for payment, to exchange for an item with the same value in cost. However, what is the true value of money and what if all of a sudden it just disappears? Physical money has become less frequent over the past years. Money has been transferred over to online banking and cards. That makes me wonder if money is truly real. Ira Glass from The NPR broadcast “The Invention of Money”, states that “money is fiction.” Yes, we are given a number to show the amount of money we have, but is that money all there? 

The NPR broadcast “The Invention of Money” explains how money is not necessarily real. It’s more of something to believe in. They stated that if you were asked to count all the money in the world, you wouldn’t be able to. Since money is liquefied it’s impossible to count. If some random person was wanting to buy a store, he would have to take money out of the bank to pay a deposit. However, the bank wouldn’t have all of the physical money to give to them. So they would have to transfer some of your own money to him. The banking system is all about transferring and borrowing money, so that everyone is satisfied without having wads of paper in storage. There is a book called, “Yap in the South Pacific”, and during that time their currency worked kind of like how ours work today. These pre-industrial people would use big stone coin shaped structures for currency. They’ve decided instead of physically trading coins or some sort of money, they would have ownership of these stone sculptures. They used this type of currency for bigger purchases. For example, if their warrior was killed in another village they would exchange ownership of the stone for their soldier. It has now evolved into how currency works today. Money has become more of an idea, numbers in the bank. Instead of being paid hundreds of dollars in cash, you’re paid online with numbers transferring from computer to another. Similar to the Yaps, we acknowledge the fact that we have money in our bank account due to the number we see. But, if you think about it, the money isn’t really there, it’s an idea. 

Similar to what the NPR broadcast talked about in the previous paragraphs, Milton Friedman, author of “The Island of Stone Money” shares the currency throughout time. His main point was about the Yap and the unique currency. How they pay forward a giant coin shaped stone sculpture in return for something treasurable.  Another point that he made was the French were frightened that the U.S would leave the gold wage currency. This led to the Federal Reserve Bank to trade dollars for gold, which caused the US to be able to exchange with other countries who have different currencies. 

In 1990, Brazil was in desperate need of help due to the extreme inflation rates with it increasing 80% per month. Sunglasses that were ten dollars in the beginning of the year would end up being 10,000 dollars by the end of the year. Brazilians didn’t realize that the value of cruizeros could change so much in such little time. Money was being printed so fast that the value of money became less and less everyday, causing inflation. However, Brazilians were so obsessed with money that they let the inflation rise to an extreme. Four economic friends were hired to assist the economy’s inflation. They created a currency called URV, a unit of real value. This currency was virtual which meant that no money existed. People can still have their standard local currency in their pockets, but they started to get paid in URVs, as well as taxes and other groceries items. I think that it is bizarre that fake money can reverse a country’s inflation and help people’s concept of money change. 

Now that the world’s currency is mostly online, we have expanded to different ways of exchanging it. One of the more common ways is cryptocurrency. In the article “The Bubble Burst on E-currency Bitcoin ” by Anne Renaut, explained how Bitcoin, the most popular cryptocurrency, dropped from 266 dollars to 54 dollars in three days. This is because it is so fluid that it is easy to fluctuate. With money being so diverse nowadays, the value of it always changes. It might decrease or increase due to the stock market, inflation and how we as people value our own money. There is never going to be one value or currency because money is being made and changed everyday. So from what I’ve learned from reading these articles and listening to the broadcast was that money doesn’t have a set value nor does it exist, it’s just an idea.

References

“The Invention of Stone Money” 423: The Inventionn of Stone Money. This is American Life, WBEZ. Chicago. 7 Jan 2011 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/423/the-invention-of-money

Friedman, Milton, “The Island of Stone Money” Diss. Hoover Institution, Stanford University, 1991https://miltonfriedman.hoover.org/internal/media/dispatcher/215061/full

Renaut, Anne “The bubble burst on e-currency Bitcoin”,13 Apr. 2013 https://phys.org/news/2013-04-e-currency-bitcoin.html

This entry was posted in DogLover, Stone Money. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Stone Money- Doglover846

  1. davidbdale says:

    You haven’t specified what sort of feedback you desire, DogLover, so I’m going to critique the ideas, paragraph by paragraph.

    1. In today’s society, money is what the world revolves around.
    —”what if it disappears?” is an intriguing question, but you don’t explain, and readers will not know what you mean by it.
    —If it’s because the physical version is being replaced by digital forms, that’s one possibility, but we still don’t know if that’s your intention.
    —Ira Glass says “money is fiction,” but HE doesn’t mean that it’s no longer physical.
    —”is that money all there?” is another intriguing question, but “there” could mean anything. Do you mean “are there physical dollar bills in a drawer with our name on them?”

    2. The NPR broadcast “The Invention of Money” explains how money is not necessarily real.
    —In this paragraph, you still haven’t decided for yourself whether you’re talking about tangible banknotes or not.
    —If “you were asked to count all the money in world” you certainly COULD, theoretically. There’s a finite, countable number of bills, coins, etc.
    —You mean, “When I deposit a check, the bank doesn’t get any banknotes. The money that goes into my account isn’t CASH.”
    —And when banks lend to borrowers from the deposits they have on hand, both I and the borrower HAVE MONEY since MINE has been LENT to them. That’s why MONEY can’t be counted.
    —You seem to be following that logic until you say, “So they would have to transfer some of your own money to him.” Readers need to know the nature of that MONEY.

    3. There is a book called, “Yap in the South Pacific”,
    —You spend this paragraph (I divided it from your Paragraph 2 since it needs a paragraph of its own) suggesting that the Yap use a system like ours (which you have presumably just explained).
    —If you started by explaining that the big stone sculptures were the equivalent of a large bank balance that stood in front of one person’s house, the similarity would be clear. Then you could say that, just as when we buy a yacht, a large part of our balance is “transferred” to the yacht seller’s account without any physical difference to the stone, we’d understand how transactions can occur without any bills and coins changing hands.

    4. Similar to what the NPR broadcast talked about in the previous paragraphs,
    —You might understand the “France’s gold” anecdote, DogLover, or you might not. I can’t tell from this paragraph.

    5. In 1990, Brazil was in desperate need of help
    —”the value of money became less and less everyday” doesn’t CAUSE inflation; it’s the DEFINITION of inflation. Flooding the economy with too much cash is what CAUSED it in this case.
    —”Brazilians were so obsessed with money. . . .” Hardly their fault. Its value decreased from the minute they got paid. They had to “think about it” or starve.
    —Very few readers can successfully explain how the URV solved inflation, but the one explanation that DOES help is that the price of a loaf of bread would be 1 URV today, and again tomorrow, and again next week, so consumers gained confidence in price stability.

    6. Now that the world’s currency is mostly online
    —You have a chance here to make a nice observation about Brazil vs Bitcoin.
    —When sunglasses cost 1000 times as much by the end of the year, WE BUY SUNGLASSES TODAY if we need them. And because everybody does the same thing, the price of sunglasses skyrockets. (INFLATION)
    —When the value of a Bitcoin goes down by 10% in one day, WE SELL BITCOIN as fast as we can. And because everybody does the same thing, the price of a single Bitcoin plummets. (DEFLATION)
    —For sure, “the value of [money] always changes.” But it always has, since the day it was invented. It buys different amounts of applesauce at different times of year. Does that mean applesauce changes value or money does? Both. The dollar is worth less applesauce when applesauce is scarce.
    —”There is never going to be one value or currency because money is being made and changed everyday.” Well . . . . there could be a single universal currency for the whole world, right? But its “value” would still fluctuate against commodities. It would buy more or less stuff depending on availability and demand of tangible things from place to place.
    —Because, as you say, “money doesn’t have a set value nor does it exist, it’s just an idea” of what somebody else will give me in return for a certain amount of it.

    Does that help, DogLover?
    Always Reply to Feedback, please, DL. It’s the primary value of the course, and I love the conversations, but I tire of them when they become one-sided. Thanks!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s