Rebuttal Rewrite (Updated)-Minutemen

Body Health or Body Image

With this need for the gym and the overwhelming growth in popularity of the fitness industry, you could make a case there are underlying motivators other than just health.  While going to the gym offers many health benefits, we see that there are also other unwanted factors such as compulsive exercise or severe critique of one’s body image.  The physiological advantages of working out can often take over a person’s life as they are addicted to these results.  This is relatable to anorexia nervosa where a person associates the act of starving themselves with the result of looking “better”.  At the start these two mindsets have positive goals such as losing some weight toning up the body, however those who struggle with excessive exercise can run their bodies into the ground from always chasing this look of lean muscle.

However, it is tough to distinguish what determines an exercise addiction.  According to Compulsive Exercise: links, risks and challenges faced, “The amount of weekly exercise is not an indicator of compulsive patterns, as the definition states that it is the physical, psychological, and social harm resulting from the exercise that is important.”  Therefore,  simply working out extremely often does not automatically categorize you as someone with compulsive exercise addiction.  There needs to be a correlation between the amount you are working out and the reason or motivation behind it.  For many, working out is a hobby and something that is apart of their routine.  However, it becomes a problem when someone is working out because they feel if they fail to workout they , in their eyes, will look physically unattractive.  This is where energy can be depleted, increased stress on the heart, chronic injury and many others occur.  In the case of repeated exercise, your body is not able to recover which can be detrimental long term.  A study was conducted on marathon runners to compare their blood samples against an average person’s.  Heart Risk Associated With Extreme Exercise found that biomarkers associated with heart damage were in the samples of the long distance runners.  These are able to be naturally repaired after some time, but if continued you can permanently scar your heart.  Research related to these studies also suggest that sudden cases of cardiac arrest were associated with over exercising.  Exercise can also be very counterintuitive.  Many seek the benefits of exercise which are increased energy and blood flow throughout the day, which can help to be more productive and to feel better.  However, when over exercising a common occurrence is completely burning yourself out which in turn stops you from exercising.  What a lot of people who struggle with this addiction will then do is when they get back they try to go even harder to make up for lost time, but then find themselves in a vicious cycle of trying to stay healthy.

Moreover, just as we see people trying to slim down through cardiovascular exercise we also see the opposite in muscle dysmorphia.  Bodybuilding is something that has become increasingly popular since the golden age somewhere between the 50’s and 70’s.  This has inspired many young adults to become infatuated with sculpting their bodies.  This however, can be taken much too far.  In a state of what many call “reverse anorexia” an individual will try to get their muscles as big and toned as possible.  In the article Is Bodybuilding a Disorder, they refer to this issue saying, “People who suffer from anorexia believe they are too big, while bodybuilders believe they are too small… both of which affect their perception of their body image.”  Both of these are just as dangerous, because if not treated they could do serious damage to internal organs.  This dysmorphia through exercise is also mentally taxing as many cases show that individuals will cut out their family, careers and other interests in order to satisfy their desire to be physically appealing.  Looking at this through a very blunt lens, we could make the case that these types of disorders wouldn’t have existed if we did not eliminate physical activity as a society.  If everyone was getting enough exercise from their daily routine, then there wouldn’t be such a fixation on trying to starve ourselves and workout profusely to make up for this lack of activity.  Many try to solve the problem of inactive lifestyles for horrible habits such as these and take drastic measures in order to achieve the physique of someone who is active daily.  We learn from these types of conditions that the body needs both rest and activity to maintain health.

Talbot, Olivia Diane, et al. “SIOWFA14 Science in Our World: Certainty and Cont.” SiOWfa14 Science in Our World Certainty and Cont, 7 Oct. 2014, 

Lakdawalla, Darius, and Tomas Philipson. “The Growth of Obesity and Technological Change.” Economics and Human Biology, U.S. National Library of Medicine, Dec. 2009, 

GoodTherapy, GoodTherapy, 

Team, Heart and Vascular. “Heart Risks Associated with Extreme Exercise.” Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, 25 Sept. 2020, 

This entry was posted in Rebuttal Rewrite. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s